Critical Social Research Ethics, 4v

Barry Smart is Professor of Sociology at the University of Portsmouth and has longstanding research interests in the fields of social theory, political economy, and philosophy. His research interests include critical social research ethics; higher education; and collaborative work on veganism, ethics, lifestyle and environment. Kay Peggs is Professor of Sociology at Kingston University (UK), Fellow of the Oxford University Centre for Animal Ethics, and Visiting Fellow in Sociology at the University of Portsmouth (UK). Previously she has worked at the universities of Warwick, Surrey, Portsmouth and Winchester. Her publications include: Identity and Repartnering after Separation (Palgrave, 2007) with Richard Lampard, Animals and Sociology (Palgrave, 2012) and numerous essays and articles in journals such as Sociology, The British Journal of Sociology, and The Sociological Review. She is co-editor of Observation Methods (Sage, 2013) and is assistant editor of the Palgrave Handbook of Practical Animal Ethics. Forthcoming publications include Experiments, Animal Bodies and Human Values (Routledge) and the co-authored book (Not) Consuming Animals: Ethics, Environment and Lifestyle Choices (Routledge), which is based on the research project she led on veganism, ethics and lifestyle.Joseph Burridge is a Senior Lecturer in Sociology at the University of Portsmouth.  Joseph has considerable editorial experience having co-edited a special issue of the journal Social Semiotics (Vol 18, Issue 3, 2008), which was re-published as an edited book Analysing Media Discourse (Routledge, 2011).  He also organised and edited a special issue of the journal Food and Foodways (Vol 20, Issue 1, 2012).    Joseph teaches research methods across the Portsmouth curriculum, as well as offering a final year module in his area of specialist interest: the sociology of food.  While Joseph’s main research interests lie in the areas of food and culture, he is also interested in the sociology of culture more generally, along with rhetoric, argumentation, discursive methods, and media representations.

• VOLUME ONECritical Reflections on Ethics in Social Research - Barry Smart and Kay PeggsPart One: Philosophy, ethics and social inquiry: themes and issuesAristotle on the Objectivity of Ethics - Robert BoltonProfessional Ethics - Emile DurkheimThe Ethics of Intellectual Life and Work - T. FowlerThe Philosophical Basis of Ethics - George H. MeadThe Sociological Basis of Ethics - Charles A. EllwoodSociology as Ethics - Edward Cary HayesScience and Ethics - Bertrand RussellMetaethics and Normative Ethics - Alan GewirthThe Position of Women as Influencing Ethics - Charlotte Perkins GilmanSocial Science Research Ethics: Historical and Philosophical Issues - Karen Strohm Kitchener and Richard KitchenerPart Two: Alternative perspectives on ethics, science and social researchEthics as a Measure of Scientific Truth - P.K. FeyerabendPostmodern Ethical Conditions and a Critical Response - Neta C. CrawfordConstrained Constructivism: Locating Scientific Inquiry in the Theater of Representation - N. Katherine HaylesFeminist Research Ethics - Judith Preissle and Yuri HanPosthuman Ethics with Cary Wolfe and Karen Barad: Animal Compassion as Trans-Species Entanglement - Florence ChiewAssembling Ethics in an Ecology of Ignorance - Paul RabinowVOLUME TWOPart One: Universities, ethical principles and the practice of social researchProfessional Ethics - Andrew AbbottEthical Influences in University Life - Crawford Howell ToyResearch Policy and Funding – Academic Treadmills and the Squeeze on Intellectual Spaces - Katherine SmithAudit Culture and Illiberal Governance: Universities and the Politics of Accountability - Cris ShoreThe Ethics of Multiple Authorship: Power, Performativity and the Gift Economy - Bruce MacfarlaneAn Analysis of the Ethics of Peer Review and Other Traditional Academic Publishing Practices - Valentine CawleyThe Academic Ethics of Open Access to Research and Scholarship - John Willinsky and Juan Pablo AlperinResearching Researchers: Lessons for Research Ethics - Rose Wiles, Vikki Charles, Graham Crow and Sue HeathMeasuring Scientific Misconduct—Lessons from Criminology - Felicitas Hesselmann, Verena Wienefoet and Martin ReinhartPart Two: Ethics committees and ethical review: analysis and critiqueResearch Ethics Committees: Values and Power in Higher Education - Ruth McAreavey and Jenny MuirResearch Participants’ Views on Ethics in Social Research: Issues for Research Ethics Committees - Jane Lewis and Jenny GrahamEthics Creep: Governing Social Science Research in the Name of Ethics - Kevin HaggertComment on Kevin D. Haggerty, “Ethics Creep: Governing Social Science Research in the Name of Ethics” - Howard S. BeckerThe Ethical Dilemma of Ethical Committees - Stuart DerbyshireConfronting the Anti-Democrats: The Unethical Nature of Ethical Regulation in Social Science - Robert DingwallConducting Research with Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual Populations: Navigating Research Ethics Board Reviews - Lea Tufford et al.Against the Ethicists: On the Evils of Ethical Regulation - Martin HammersleyExtending the Olive Branch: Enhancing Communication and Trust between Research Ethics Committees and Qualitative Researchers - Suzanne McMurphy, Jacqueline Lewis and Pierre BoulosSeeking University Research Ethics Committee Approval: The Emotional Vicissitudes of a ‘Rationalised’ Process - Lee F. Monaghan, Maria O’Dwyer and Jonathan GabeAre Research Ethics Committees Behaving Unethically? Some Suggestions for Improving Performance and Accountability - Julian Savulescu, Iain Chalmers and Jennifer BluntThe Case against Ethics Review in the Social Sciences - Zachary SchragReputational Risk, Academic Freedom and Research Ethics Review - Adam HedgecoeVOLUME THREEPart One: (Un)ethical Research, Contested Knowledge and Critical Social InquiryTracking the Truth or Selling One′s Soul? Reflections on the Ethics of a Piece of Commissioned Research - Vince HamTen Lies of Ethnography: Moral Dilemmas of Field Research - Gary Alan FineClinical Research Fraud - Jane BarrettThe Ethics of Using Medical Data from Nazi Experiments - Baruch CohenThe Ethics of Social Research: The Tuskegee Syphilis Study - Sharlene Nagy Hesse-Biber and Patricia LeavyAfrican Americans’ Views on Research and the Tuskegee Syphilis Study - Vicki Freimuth et al.Some Conditions of Obedience and Disobedience to Authority - Stanley Milgram“Torture at Yale”: Experimental Subjects Laboratory Torment and the “Rehabilitation” of Milgram’s “Obedience to Authority” - Ian NicholsonPromises, Promises: Lessons in Research Ethics from the Belfast Project and the “Rape Tape” Case - Kay InklePhilosophical Reflections on Experimenting with Human Subjects - Hans JonasAn Unfortunate Experiment at National Women’s - Sandra Coney and Phillida BunklePart Two: Questions of Ethics, Consent, and ConfidentialityEthics in Action: Consent–Gaining Interactions and Implications for Research Practice - Susan Speer and Elizabeth StokoeRemoving the ‘Gag’: Involving People with Dementia in Research as Advisers and Participants - Jenni Brooks, Nada Savitch and Kate GridleyConsent and Informed Consent: Their Ongoing Evolutions in Clinical Care and Research on Humans - Dennis J. MazurResearch without Consent - Paul Spicker“You Still Takin’ Notes?” Fieldwork and Problems of Informed Consent - Barrie ThorneThe Betrayal of Research Confidentiality in British Sociology - John Lowmans and Ted PalysFour Pillars of Internet Research Ethics with Web 2.0 - Barry RookeInformed Consent and the Facebook Emotional Manipulation Study - Catherine FlickVOLUME FOURPart One: Divisions, Differences, and Diversity: Critical Ethical Dilemmas in Social ResearchReflections and Recommendations on Research Ethics in Developing Countries - S.R. BenatarEthnic Diversity and Inequality: Ethical and Scientific Rigour in Social Research - Sarah Salway et al.Ethical Challenges in Mental Health Research among Internally Displaced People: Ethical Theory and Research Implementation - Chesmal Siriwardhana et al.Women, Genocide and Memory: The Ethics of Feminist Ethnography in Holocaust Research - Janet Liebman JacobsPhilsophy, Ethics and the Disability Community - Martin SullivanThe Problem of Speaking for Others - Linda AlcoffSpeaking about Others and Speaking Personally: Reflections after Elspeth Probyn′s Sexing the Self - Nick CouldryWhere Are Human Subjects in Big Data Research? The Emerging Ethics Divide - Jacob Metcalf and Kate CrawfordPart Two: Elites and Social Research: Critical EngagementsElites: Remembered in Capitalism and Forgotten in Social Sciences - Mike Savage and Karel WilliamsMethodological Dilemmas and Opportunities in Interviewing Organizational Elites - Kevin DelaneyCulture, Power, and Social Disparity: Researching Russia’s Upper Class - Elisabeth SchimpfosslOn Studying the Powerful (or Fearing to Do So): A Vital Role for IRBs - Joan SieberEthics and Politics of Studying Up in Technoscience - Diana Forsythe“Surely You’re Not in This Just to Be Helpful” Access, Rapport and Interviews in Three Studies of Elites - Susan A. OstranderToday’s Intellectuals: Too Obedient? - Fred Inglis