Hemlock Falls is one of the most picturesque villages in upstate New York, with the Hemlock Inn, owned by the amateur sleuths, the Quilliam sisters, as its center piece. The Quillliam sisters would love the show their little slice of paradise to the tourists that come to stay at their historic inn, however, the village isn’t as peaceful as the picturesque quaint would have you believe…

For the Quilliam sisters, there’s nothing jolly about this Christmas. Meg and Quill are near-broke. At least there’s one bright start on the horizon: a big-time magazine and television show will feature the Inn. But soon the editor’s husband skis to his death. Now, if the Quilliams are to save the Inn from a lawsuit, they’ll need to prove this was no accident.