John Henry Newman's an Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent

“Newman’s Grammar of Assent is one of the great works of the Catholic intellectual tradition in modern times, a book that anticipates some of the most important developments in subsequent epistemology and applies them with care and precision to basic theological questions. Yet it often falls between the cracks. Theologians tend to shy away from it because it seems too philosophical, and philosophers because it seems too theological. This fine collection of essays by philosophical and theological readers of the Grammar should go a long way toward securing for Newman’s singular work the recognition it deserves in our own time.” - Bruce D. Marshall Southern Methodist University“This critical guide, with first-class essays expertly curated by Aquino and Levering, offers an illuminating exploration of St. John Henry Newman’s An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent, one of the most significant—if perhaps criminally underread—works in Catholic philosophy and theology. With a keen focus on Newman’s concept of assent within his broader epistemology, the contributors are also able to situate his thought not only in dialogue with other great thinkers like Aristotle, Pascal, Locke, Butler, and Bouyer, but also to suggest how the Grammar is related to many of his other major texts and more expansive theological and philosophical vision. While the collection of methodologically distinct contributions from history, philosophy, and theology is clearly an interdisciplinary tour de force appropriate to Newman’s own intellectual range and richness, it hangs together beautifully. Indeed, the volume bears within it the marks of genuine collaboration, even friendship, between its contributors: urgency, intimacy, sharpness, liveliness, and depth, as it seeks to make this neglected text more accessible to students and scholars alike.” - Jennifer Newsome Martin University of Notre Dame“Newman’s An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent is widely regarded as one of his most significant and original works, though it is also among his most challenging. This is in part because, while the Grammar of Assent is a theoretical work, it is also a deeply personal one. The ideas in the Grammar did not arise out of a well-defined school of thought but rather out of a lifetime of reflection on the relationship between reason, belief, and faith, both in Newman’s own person and in those close to him. As a result, the significance of the Grammar can be lost to the contemporary reader. This collection of essays, authored by leading Newman scholars in philosophy and theology, is a great resource for understanding this important text. By addressing the central ideas of the Grammar with clarity and depth, the essays offer both an accessible introduction for scholars new to Newman’s thought and a treasure trove of insights for seasoned readers.” - Joe Milburn University of Navarra

• About the ContributorsAcknowledgmentsIntroductionChapter 1: Situating Newman’s Grammar of Assent Geertjan ZuijdwegtChapter 2: Notional and Real Apprehension in Newman’s Grammar of AssentJohn F. CrosbyChapter 3: Understanding Real and Notional Assent in the GrammarLorraine Juliano KellerChapter 4: The Dogmatic Proposition in Newman’s Grammar of AssentAndrew MeszarosChapter 5: The Critical Role of Conscience in Newman’s Grammar of AssentChristopher CimorelliChapter 6: Faith in An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of AssentFrancesca Aran MurphyChapter 7: Pascalian Themes in Newman’s Grammar: Whose Rationality? Which Deity?Thomas S. HibbsChapter 8: Assent, Inference, and Inquiry in John Henry Newman’s Grammar of Assent Stephen R. GrimmChapter 9: Newman’s Illative Sense Re-Examined Logan Paul Gage and Frederick D. AquinoChapter 10: Natural and Revealed Religion in Chapter 10 of the Grammar of AssentCyril O’ReganBibliographyIndex