Overwhelmed by caring for her accident-prone younger brother and keeping up with constant housework and chaos he creates, Lavina Fisher is convinced she'll never make a good wife and mother. Her longterm boyfriend, Amish EMT Aaron Yoder, is heartbroken over their breakup, but he offers to keep an eye on her brother during a Lancaster County mud sale. He's a calming influence on young Stephen, until the boy's exuberance soon leads him into major trouble, Can this major catastrophe bring them back together, or will it drive them further apart?