When James sees Andrew at a gay coffee shop, the attraction is immediate. They exchange smiles and Andrew makes friendly overtures, so they go for a walk and end up at Andrew's apartment. As they begin spending time together, James's friends are supportive but cautious. One of the men Andrew has been seen with in the coffee shop was a known Republican supporter. James dismisses the dark implications of this, carefully avoiding any talk of politics with his new boyfriend. Then James's friend Glen makes a horrible discovery while visiting Andrew's place with James: Andrew has a MAGA cap hidden in his chest of drawers. He takes a picture of it and confronts James with the evidence. James has fallen in love, but he knows he faces a terrible hurdle. Can he love a man who apparently is a member of the hateful MAGA movement?