Shared Histories

Benjamin Pogrund, Paul Scham, Walid Salem

".unpredictable and surprising.the book abounds with subversive historical gems that contradict narrative dogma. This series of erudite exchanges sets the entry bar high in terms of background knowledge. It is an insider's portrait of the complex, nuanced and alternately complementary and skeptical relationships of a group of Israeli and Palestinian professional historians to each other's work, and to the dominant narratives in whose shadow they operate. Through it all, the participants move seamlessly between critiquing and defending their own and each other's narratives. No one hews blindly to orthodox interpretations, and it is difficult to predict opinions based on identity; these historians think for themselves and say unexpected things. Shared Histories is a rare example of Israeli/Palestinian conflict discussion-among academics, no less-that defies the laws of negative interdependence. The quality and collegiality of the discussions is particularly notable, given that they occurred during the most lethal period of Israeli/Palestinian violence since 1948. If Israeli and Palestinian intellectuals can engage in dialogue of this level, at that time, it should be possible to debate these issues substantially and productively in academic forums further removed from the conflict." -Israel Studies Forum "As the peace process in Palestine lurches along and cynicism grows about the possibility of ever having a just, lasting and comprehensive settlement, it is refreshing to come across Shared Histories, which is both hard-nosed and hopeful. .The juxtaposition of solid scholarship with all-too-human debate on issues underpinning the question of the Right of Return and other hot topics makes reading Shared Histories especially relevant." -Palestine-Israel Journal 13, 2 "The reader, whether steeped in the history of the conflict of simply looking for some explanation of why it is so intractable, sees through the eyes of the protagonists themselves why mutual understanding is so difficult and, in the process, begins to understand why the two sides have not been able to come to terms." -Edy Kaufman, University of Maryland and Hebrew University of Jerusalem (emeritus) "This rare book will help inform Israelis and Palestinians of each other's narrative, as well as identify points of agreements, which will contribute to diminishing the misunderstanding and hostility that have undermined peace efforts and reconciliation." -Philip J. Mattar, Editor, The Encyclopedia of the Palestinians, and former Senior Fellow at the United States Institute of Peace "The participants move seamlessly between critiquing and defending their own and each other's narratives. No one hews blindly to orthodox interpretations, and it is difficult to predict opinions based on identity; these historians think for themselves and say unexpected things. Shared Histories is a rare example of Israeli-Palestinian conflict discussion-among academics, no less-that defies the laws of negative interdependence. The quality and collegiality of the discussions is particularly notable, given that they occurred during the most lethal period of Israeli-Palestinian violence since 1948. If Israeli and Palestinian intellectuals could engage in dialogue of this level, at that time, it should be possible to debate these issues substantially and productively in academic forums further removed from the conflict... [it] reads like Talmud: the shorthand minutes of alternately esoteric, fractious, and profound exchanges between learned authorities, fragmented, marked by subtlety, allusion and sophisticated hints of sub-textual dynamics." - Israel Studies Forum

• Introduction; Chapter 1 Napoleon to Allenby: Processes of Change in Palestine, 1800'“1918, Ruth Kark; Chapter 2 Continuity and Change in Palestine: The Late Ottoman Period, 1856'“1918, Adel Manna; Chapter 3 Discussion 1, Ruth Kark, Adel Manna; Chapter 4 The Beginnings of Jewish Settlement and Zionism to World War I, Ran Aaronsohn; Chapter 5 The Pre-History of Palestinian Nationalism, Issam Nassar; Chapter 6 Discussion 2, Ran Aaronsohn, Qaymari Ata, Nassar Issam; Chapter 7 Development of the Palestinian National Movement, 1919'“1939, Manuel Hassassian; Chapter 8 Zionist Diplomacy, 1914'“1939, Norman Rose; Chapter 9 Discussion 3, Manuel Hassassian, Norman Rose; Chapter 10 The Holocaust, the Creation of Israel, and the Shaping of Israeli Society, Dalia Ofer; Chapter 11 The Holocaust in the Palestinian Perspective, Ata Qaymari; Chapter 12 Discussion 4, Dalia Ofer, Ata Qaymari; Chapter 13 The U.N. Part Ition Resolution of 1947: Why Wasn't It Implemented?, Moshe Ma'oz; Chapter 14 Paradoxes of the U.N. 1947 Part Ition Plan, Walid Salem; Chapter 15 Discussion 5, Moshe Ma'oz, Walid Salem; Chapter 16 Israeli Historiography of the 1948 War, Avraham Sela; Chapter 17, Adel H. Yahya; Chapter 18 Discussion 6, Avraham Sela, Adel Yahya; Chapter 19 Holiness and Politics in the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict, Moshe Amirav; Chapter 20 Jerusalem Refugees and Property Claims Since the 1948 War, Salim Tamari; Chapter 21 Discussion 7, Moshe Amirav, Sabella Bernard, Tamari Salim;