'Macario Giraldo has taken on a formidable task, the study of psychoanalytic groups using the lens and translation of Jacques Lacan. Although Lacan was not a group analyst, he was strongly influenced by the work of Bion and Rickman. Not only does Dr Giraldo make Lacan accessible, but also he brings his own joy and excitement to the reader. Clinicians and social scientists will enjoy this fresh multi-disciplined approach to the work of Lacan.'- Beatrice Liebenberg, MSW, Distinguished Fellow, American Group Psychotherapy Association Faculty, The Washington School of Psychiatry'Macario Giraldo's book is important for many reasons, in particular for succeeding in the demanding task of applying Lacanian principles used in individual therapy to group work. What Macario Giraldo's book has done in bringing French ideas into English, and psychoanalysis to group analysis, is an important achievement and a pioneering work in the field. He links Lacanian theoretical development with the group phenomenon in a way that brings the ideas to life. His explanations are clear but without simplifications. He does not shy from using his own subjectivity carefully to bring the reader to an appreciation of the subject. He has the gift of keeping the reader so involved that he is unable to stop reading this book until the very last chapter.'- Claude Spielmann, a psychoanalyst in Paris and member of Le Cercle Freudien'The Dialogues in and of the Group is a most welcome book. Offering access to unconscious processes as informed by the work of Jacques Lacan, it is a highly readable primer for all practitioners interested in the application of the principles of Lacanian psychoanalysis. to groups and group work. Well argued and clearly written. Macario Giraldo develops the idea of two basic dialogues` operative at different levels in the group. One is the dialogue between individual group members and the other the dialogue of the group as a whole, the latter bringing out what the author calls "the signifier of desire". To distinguish the two, he focuses on Lacans crucial concepts of the Imaginary, the Symbolic and the Real whose interplay he illustrates by a wealth of clinical material which I am sure will be of interest to clinicians of all schools.- Dieter Nitzgen, MA, group analyst (GAS International, IGA/Heidelberg), psychoanalyst (Association of Freudian Psychoanalysis)'The conceptual space separating group analysis and Lacanian theory is too wide. This lucid text offers the reader a welcome bridge across this space. My pleasure in reading was enhanced by the evident joy that Macario Giraldo takes in being able to show how he uses Lacan's ideas to further his understanding of the group processes. Fortunately, there is a growing convergence between Foulkesian group analysis in the recognition of discourse, and dialogue in and of the group. My repeated efforts to grasp the values of Lacanian theories are replaced by appreciation as Giraldo lays out before us his growing understanding of his patients' experiences in groups. I resonate to these words: "I have found in Lacan powerful incentives... to understand and reach a bit closer to the human in me and in my patients." It was a particular pleasure to find that both Lacan and Foulkes enjoyed listening to barber shop conversations. Giraldo is passionate, humorous, serious: a very fine teacher.'- Malcolm Pines, FRCPsych., DPM [dist.], past President, International Association of Group Psychotherapy and former Consultant, Tavistock Clinic, London, and Maudsley Hospital, London
