Lara Buchak is Associate Professor of Philosophy at the University of California at BerkeleyDean W. Zimmerman is Professor of Philosophy at Rutgers University. Philip Swenson (co-editor for Volume 9) is Assistant Professor of Philosophy at the College of William & Mary

• 1: Alexander R. Pruss and Hilary Yancey: Privation in the Problem of Evil: Impairment, Health, Wellbeing, and a Case of Humans and Betazoids 2: Paul Draper: What if God Makes Hard Choices? 3: Klaas J. Kraay: Theism, Pro-Theism, and Gratuitous Evil 4: William Hasker: God and Gratuitous Evil: A Response to Klass Kraay 5: Rebecca Chan and Dustin Crummett: Moral Indulgences: When Offsetting is Wrong 6: Frances Howard-Snyder: Time of Trial 7: Mark Johnston: Why The One Did Not Remain In Itself 8: Noah Lemos: Organic Unities, Summation, and the Problem of Evil 9: Michael Zimmerman: Organic Unities and the Problem of Evil: A Reply to Lemos 10: Bruce Langtry: Unrestricted Actualization and Divine Providence 11: Michael Almeida: Unrestricted Actualization and Perfect Worlds: A Reply to Langtry 12: Bruce Langtry: Predication and Providence: Rejoinder to Almeida's Reply 13: Scott A. Davison: A Naturalistic Intrinsic Value Theodicy Index

Lara Buchak is Associate Professor of Philosophy at the University of California at BerkeleyDean W. Zimmerman is Professor of Philosophy at Rutgers University. Philip Swenson (co-editor for Volume 9) is Assistant Professor of Philosophy at the College of William & Mary

• 1: Alexander R. Pruss and Hilary Yancey: Privation in the Problem of Evil: Impairment, Health, Wellbeing, and a Case of Humans and Betazoids 2: Paul Draper: What if God Makes Hard Choices? 3: Klaas J. Kraay: Theism, Pro-Theism, and Gratuitous Evil 4: William Hasker: God and Gratuitous Evil: A Response to Klass Kraay 5: Rebecca Chan and Dustin Crummett: Moral Indulgences: When Offsetting is Wrong 6: Frances Howard-Snyder: Time of Trial 7: Mark Johnston: Why The One Did Not Remain In Itself 8: Noah Lemos: Organic Unities, Summation, and the Problem of Evil 9: Michael Zimmerman: Organic Unities and the Problem of Evil: A Reply to Lemos 10: Bruce Langtry: Unrestricted Actualization and Divine Providence 11: Michael Almeida: Unrestricted Actualization and Perfect Worlds: A Reply to Langtry 12: Bruce Langtry: Predication and Providence: Rejoinder to Almeida's Reply 13: Scott A. Davison: A Naturalistic Intrinsic Value Theodicy Index

Lara Buchak is Associate Professor of Philosophy at the University of California at BerkeleyDean W. Zimmerman is Professor of Philosophy at Rutgers University. Philip Swenson (co-editor for Volume 9) is Assistant Professor of Philosophy at the College of William & Mary

• 1: Alexander R. Pruss and Hilary Yancey: Privation in the Problem of Evil: Impairment, Health, Wellbeing, and a Case of Humans and Betazoids 2: Paul Draper: What if God Makes Hard Choices? 3: Klaas J. Kraay: Theism, Pro-Theism, and Gratuitous Evil 4: William Hasker: God and Gratuitous Evil: A Response to Klass Kraay 5: Rebecca Chan and Dustin Crummett: Moral Indulgences: When Offsetting is Wrong 6: Frances Howard-Snyder: Time of Trial 7: Mark Johnston: Why The One Did Not Remain In Itself 8: Noah Lemos: Organic Unities, Summation, and the Problem of Evil 9: Michael Zimmerman: Organic Unities and the Problem of Evil: A Reply to Lemos 10: Bruce Langtry: Unrestricted Actualization and Divine Providence 11: Michael Almeida: Unrestricted Actualization and Perfect Worlds: A Reply to Langtry 12: Bruce Langtry: Predication and Providence: Rejoinder to Almeida's Reply 13: Scott A. Davison: A Naturalistic Intrinsic Value Theodicy Index