Kant and Skepticism

Michael N. Forster is professor of philosophy at the University of Chicago. His books include "Wittgenstein on the Arbitrariness of Grammar" (Princeton), "Hegel's Idea of a Phenomenology of Spirit", and "Hegel and Skepticism".

"In this precise, lively work, Forster establishes the significance of skepticism in the motivation, development, and formulation of Kant's thought. He examines three varieties of skepticism: 'veil of perception skepticism' concerning the external world, which he interprets as secondary for Kant despite its priority in previous literature; 'Humean skepticism' concerning the possibility of a priori knowledge; and 'Pyrrhonian skepticism,' employing a 'zetetic method' of equipollence and antinomies in order to suspend judgment... Forster concludes, however, that Kant's reliance on transcendental arguments and transcendental idealism reintroduces the skeptical problems they were meant to resolve through inadequate self-reflection and radical skepticism's revenge on Kant's incorporation of its moderate variant."--E. S. Nelson, University of Massachusetts Lowell, for CHOICE "[N]o one interested in the basic issues of Kant's theoretical philosophy can afford to neglect Forster's elegantly written (and produced) book, and it should prove particularly valuable for stimulating discussion in courses on Kant's first Critique."--Paul Guyer, Philosophical Review "The message is persuasive and ingeniously conveyed in an enjoyable and refreshing book. I recommend Kant and Skepticism to Kant scholars, those interested in skepticism, and those interested in Hegel's criticisms of Kant."--Craig French, Heythrop Journal "I highly recommend this book to those working on Kant's philosophy, the general history of modern skepticism, or the influence of Pyrrhonism on modern thought."--Diego E. Machuca, Philosophy in Review "Kant and Skepticism is an excellent book that is well worth thinking about long and hard, and will also, I predict, be a much discussed contribution to Kant studies in the foreseeable future."--Robert Hanna, Philosophical Quarterly "[T]he reviewer suspects that his fellow Anglophones will find Forster's book interesting, challenging, and enlightening, but probably something short of heretical... The great strength of Kant and Skepticism is that it neatly slices one set of issues from the complex whole of the first Critique, allowing Forster and the reader with him to assess a particular, extremely important question about Kant's philosophy."--Ted Kinnaman, Kant-Studien

• Preface ix PART I : EXPOSITION CHAPTER ONE: Varieties of Skepticism 3 CHAPTER TWO: "Veil of Perception" Skepticism 6 CHAPTER THREE: Skepticism and Metaphysics (a Puzzle) 13 CHAPTER FOUR: Kant's Pyrrhonian Crisis 16 CHAPTER FIVE: Humean Skepticism 21 CHAPTER SIX: Kant's Reformed Metaphysics 33 CHAPTER SEVEN: Defenses against Humean Skepticism 40 CHAPTER EIGHT: Defenses against Pyrrhonian Skepticism 44 PART II : CRITICAL ASSESSMENT CHAPTER NINE: Some Relatively Easy Problems 55 CHAPTER TEN: A Metaphysics of Morals? 58 CHAPTER ELEVEN: Failures of Self-Reflection 63 CHAPTER TWELVE: The Pyrrhonist's Revenge 76 Notes 93 Index 149