María E Hernández -Torrales – författare

When the first community land trusts (CLTs) began appearing in the United States during the 1970s, all were located in rural areas. By the 1980s and 1990s, this innovative form of tenure was spreading into cities, suburbs, and towns. Homeownership remained a priority for urban CLTs, but other applications got added to the mix: revitalizing distressed neighborhoods; preventing displacement in gentrifying neighborhoods; and developing multiple types of affordable housing beyond the detached, single-family houses that had been the programmatic focus of CLTs in more rural areas.

Urban CLTs also went beyond housing. On scattered parcels of land which they owned and stewarded on a community''s behalf, CLTs sponsored stores, restaurants, clinics, community centers, and facilities for other nonprofit organizations, providing a variety of goods and services for local residents. A few urban CLTs made lands available for greenhouses, community gardens, and commercial agriculture.        

Today, as community land trusts have spread far beyond the United States, most are urban. There are still countries where new CLTs are being formed in rural areas, but the greatest growth in the global CLT movement is occurring in the densely populated neighborhoods and inner-ring suburbs of cities. Most of this growth has happened in the Global North, with cities like Boston, Brussels, Denver, London, Montreal, and Toronto leading the way. More recently, urban CLTs have begun appearing in the Global South as well. The Fideicomiso de la Tierra del Caño Martín Peña in San Juan, Puerto Rico and the ongoing efforts to seed CLTs in the favelas of Rio de Janeiro are pointing the way. 

Urban CLTs operate at the intersection of two world-wide movements for social change. The first is happening where people who occupy acreage under some form an informal landholding system are struggling to gain security of tenure. Many of these informal settlements are at the center or on the periphery of major cities in Africa, Asia, Latin America, and the Caribbean.  

CLTs are also aligned with a rising tide of advocacy around housing rights, happening in cities across the world. The strategies championed by this amorphous movement for a "right to the city" include rent control, the production of housing that remains permanently affordable, and resistance to the removal of classes and races from areas experiencing government investment in major infrastructure or private investment in upscale development. 

Urban issues and actions like these provided the backdrop for a collection of twenty-six original essays published by Terra Nostra Press, On Common Ground: International Perspectives on the Community Land Trust.

As community land trusts (CLTs) have grown in number and spread around the world, the model itself has changed. There are now many variations of what is sometimes known as the "classic" CLT. What has not changed, however, is the dynamic tension between impactful development and community empowerment that was baked into the structure and purpose of the CLT from the very beginning. 

Every community land trust attempts to gain control over enough land, housing, and other land-based assets to make a difference in the lives of low-income and moderate-income people. At the same time as it is expanding its portfolio of real estate, a CLT is also dedicated to expanding and engaging its social base--continuously organizing, informing, and involving members of its chosen community in guiding and governing the CLT itself. Ownership and empowerment go hand-in-hand.

These dual goals are often seen as incompatible within the larger field of community development. Even within the smaller world of CLTs, there is an ongoing debate as to whether there exists an inevitable tradeoff between going to scale versus ceding control to the community served by a CLT. 

That debate is the focus of the present monograph. Although several contributors take one side or the other, most portray the CLT as occupying a rhetorical and practical middle ground between impact and empowerment. They provide examples of successful CLTs in which involving residents in guiding and governing the organization has been the basis for increasing a CLT''s holdings of land and housing, rather than being a barrier to growth. In these organizations, the dual goals of a CLT are reconciled and brought skillfully, sustainably into balance. 

All of the chapters in the present monograph, except for the opening essay by Emily Thaden and Tony Pickett, were selected from On Common Ground: International Perspectives on the Community Land Trust. This earlier collection of twenty-six original essays was published by Terra Nostra Press in June 2020. 

During the fifty years since the first community land trust (CLT) was founded by African-American civil rights activists in the United States, CLTs have spread far beyond their country of origin. Most of this growth has occurred in the Global North, but CLTs are now also being formed in a growing number of countries in the Global South. 

The fertile seedbed for CLT development in this part of the world has been informal settlements. These are residential areas where people have built their own homes, usually without regard for whatever governmental standards, codes, or regulations that might exist. They have sited their self-built homes, moreover, on lands to which they lack a legal right of ownership or occupancy. Many of these settlements have existed for several generations. Buildings, community ties, and a way of life have become firmly established, even as the residents'' tenure has remained precarious.

Community land trusts are being promoted by community activists in the Global South as a resident-led strategy for formalizing tenure and securing people''s homes in communities like these. Several chapters in the present monograph focus on the formation or exploration of CLTs in urban areas, including densely populated informal settlements in San Juan, Puerto Rico; Rio de Janeiro, Brazil; Voi, Kenya; Karachi, Pakistan; and Dhaka, Bangladesh. Another chapter focuses on a remote rural area of Honduras, where a CLT is working to secure the watersheds on which widely dispersed mountain villages depend. 

All of the monograph''s chapters, except for the opening essay by Patricia De Toledo Basile and Meagan M. Ehlenz, were selected from On Common Ground: International Perspectives on the Community Land Trust. This earlier collection of twenty-six original essays was published by Terra Nostra Press in June 2020. 

El fideicomiso comunitario de tierras es una estrategia transformadora en la que el desarrollo es dirigido por la comunidad en terrenos comunitarios. Esta estrategia está tomando auge a través de comunidades en el norte global y también se está comenzando a conocer en el sur global. Los fideicomisos comunitarios de tierras producen y mantienen viviendas, espacios comerciales, tierras para la agricultura urbana (y rural) y una variedad de instalaciones comunitarias a precios asequibles-todas desarrolladas con el auspicio de la comunidad; y todas administradas para mantenerse asequibles a perpetuidad para personas de ingresos bajos o moderados. Cuando los gobiernos, organizaciones caritativas u otras organizaciones no gubernamentales emprenden el mejoramiento de una comunidad surgen preguntas sobre ¿quién decide lo que se hará? y ¿quién se beneficiará? Debido a la manera en que estos fideicomisos administran sus activos y debido a su gobernanza participativa, estos ofrecen nuevas contestaciones a dichas preguntas.

No todos los fideicomisos comunitarios de tierras son iguales. Entre los cientos fideicomisos comunitarios establecidos en una docena de diferentes países existen variaciones sobre cómo se estructuran estas organizaciones, qué uso dan a sus tierras, cómo realizan los desarrollos, y cómo se administran y cuidan los activos para futuras generaciones. Pueden diferenciarse de una localidad a otra. No empece la falta de uniformidad, las personas que abogan por este tipo de estrategia y la ponen en práctica han podido desarrollar argumentos consistentes a favor de ésta. Esencialmente expresan que: Cuando la tierra se posee para el bienestar de una comunidad, presente y futura; cuando el desarrollo lo realiza una organización creada por la comunidad, cimentada en tal comunidad, con sentido de responsabilidad hacia ésta, y guiada por ésta; cuando la administración es deliberada, diligente y duradera ... es más probable que el desarrollo sea tanto equitativo como sostenible, especialmente en lugares cuya población se encuentra en desventaja y carente de poder.

Los ensayos contenidos en este monográfico provienen de un libro titulado En terreno común: Perspectivas internacionales sobre los fideicomisos comunitarios de tierras. La mayoría de los veintiséis capítulos contenidos en dicho libro se enfocan en la descripción de las condiciones, organización, y políticas que dieron lugar a la creación de un fideicomiso comunitario de tierras tanto en el escenario urbano como rural. Un número de los capítulos también ofrecen un análisis de la filosofía detrás de este acercamiento no convencional a la tenencia de la tierra. Exploran justificaciones de carácter ético, político, y práctico para la creación de un fideicomiso comunitario de tierras. Son estos ensayos los que componen este monográfico. En conjunto, proveen una justificación coherente y convincente de la razón por la cual los fideicomisos comunitarios de tierras son dignos de consideración, implementación y apoyo.